Invisible Discrimination as Manifestation of Symbolic Capital: A Marxist analysis of the selected South Asian fiction
Title: Invisible Discrimination as Manifestation of Symbolic Capital: A Marxist Analysis of
the Selected South Asian Fiction
This thesis conducts a Marxist analysis of the novels "The White Tiger" by Aravind Adiga, "The
Ministry of Utmost Happiness" by Arundhati Roy, and "How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia"
by Mohsin Hamid, focusing on invisible discrimination as a manifestation of symbolic capital.
Drawing on theories of recognition, symbolic capital, and violence, the research aims to uncover
the role of recognition of symbolic capital in perpetuating invisible discrimination and how it is
utilized to elevate social class status. By examining the characters and their experiences within
these novels, the study explores the dynamics of power, privilege, and marginalization. It
investigates how dominant social groups establish and maintain hierarchies that devalue minority
languages, cultures, and identities, leading to the internalization of shame and pressure to
assimilate into the dominant group. The analysis employs a Marxist lens to reveal the mechanisms
through which symbolic capital is employed to uphold class distinctions. The findings contribute
to a deeper understanding of the complexities surrounding invisible discrimination and emphasize
the importance of challenging and dismantling the symbolic capital that perpetuates inequality and
oppression. The research underscores the need for recognition of marginalized voices and
advocates for the pursuit of social justice and equality within contemporary societies
Extropianism, Human Cloning and the Ethical Question: A Transhumanist Critique of the Contemporary Science Fiction
Title: Extropianism, Human Cloning and the Ethical Question: A Transhumanist
Critique of the Contemporary Science Fiction
This research study has attempted to explore transhumanist, ethical, and societal concerns
raised by human cloning in the novels; The Lost Girl by Sangu Mandanna and Constance
by Matthew Fitzsimmons. I have applied Max More’s extropian principles and Leon Kass’
ethical theory as a lens to analyze the selected texts. The research method used for the
analysis of selected texts is the textual analysis by Catherine Belsey. In 1997, with the birth
of Dolly, the first cloned sheep came the inception of debate on the topic of cloning.
Extropianism sees human cloning as a progressive step in improving the human condition,
but this raises numerous ethical concerns that clash with their ideas and notions. Science
fiction has produced numerous works based on human cloning which address both sides of
the argument concerning the promotion and negation of human cloning. This study
identifies several ethical and societal concerns raised by human cloning in the selected
texts; man is playing at being God by trying to make replicas of human beings, no matter
how much advancement science and technology make in cloning technology man can never
make an exact replacement of a human being either dead or alive, several acceptance and
identity issue arise that prove to be very disturbing for both humans and clones. This
research inspires future researchers to address the serious threats related to ethical and
moral issues posed by human cloning. This study will benefit and help future researchers
as a stimulus in transhuman studies.
Depiction of Afghan Peace Process through semantic prosody: A corpus-based critical study of print media discourse
Title: Depiction of Afghan Peace Process through Semantic Prosody: A
Corpus-Based Critical Study of Print Media Discourse
After over 20 years of an unsuccessful attempt to dislodge the Taliban from Afghanistan,
the US administration was finally ready to sign a peace treaty with them on February 9,
2020. The linguistic portrayal of this historical event has received massive coverage in
print media worldwide concerning their national interests and their engagement with the
Afghan peace process. The current study is conducted to linguistically investigate the
Afghan peace process covered in English newspapers by combining two methodological
perspectives; corpus linguistics (CL) and critical discourse analysis (CDA). This study
identified the construction of the Afghan peace process in the corpora compiled from the
six selected English newspapers, such as The Dawn, The Express Tribune, The
Afghanistan Times, The Kabul Times, The Washington Post, and The New York Times,
published from February 29, 2020, to August 31, 2021, in Pakistan, Afghanistan, and the
USA respectively. The researcher selected only two text categories from the selected
newspapers, including opinion articles and editorials. Moreover, the researcher employed
three corpus tools, i.e., keyword lists, collocation, and concordance, through the lexical
software AntConc 4.2.0 to achieve the objectives of the study. Furthermore, the linguistic
patterns in concordance lines in each corpus were examined using Stubbs' (1996) model
of discourse prosody to examine the viewpoint of each newspaper. The findings of this
study reveal that the newspapers of the selected countries depicted the same issue
differently based on their interests and liabilities. More specifically, the same discourse
patterns have been portrayed differently (negatively or positively) by each country's
media. This study emphasises the need to investigate the language and discursive
practices used in media discourse to extract public opinion on a certain political issue
Invisible Discrimination as Manifestation of Symbolic Capital: A Marxist analysis of the selected South Asian fiction
Title: Invisible Discrimination as Manifestation of Symbolic Capital: A Marxist Analysis of
the Selected South Asian Fiction
This thesis conducts a Marxist analysis of the novels "The White Tiger" by Aravind Adiga, "The
Ministry of Utmost Happiness" by Arundhati Roy, and "How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia"
by Mohsin Hamid, focusing on invisible discrimination as a manifestation of symbolic capital.
Drawing on theories of recognition, symbolic capital, and violence, the research aims to uncover
the role of recognition of symbolic capital in perpetuating invisible discrimination and how it is
utilized to elevate social class status. By examining the characters and their experiences within
these novels, the study explores the dynamics of power, privilege, and marginalization. It
investigates how dominant social groups establish and maintain hierarchies that devalue minority
languages, cultures, and identities, leading to the internalization of shame and pressure to
assimilate into the dominant group. The analysis employs a Marxist lens to reveal the mechanisms
through which symbolic capital is employed to uphold class distinctions. The findings contribute
to a deeper understanding of the complexities surrounding invisible discrimination and emphasize
the importance of challenging and dismantling the symbolic capital that perpetuates inequality and
oppression. The research underscores the need for recognition of marginalized voices and
advocates for the pursuit of social justice and equality within contemporary societies.
Representation of Kumara’s murder in Pakistan and Srilankan English newspaper: A Transitivity analysis
Title: Representation of Mob Violence in Pakistani and Sri Lankan Newspapers: A
Transitivity Analysis
Transitivity analysis is a linguistic framework that focuses on analyzing the ways in
which participants, actions, and circumstances are represented in discourse to get the
hidden meaning out of the text. It is a central concept in Systemic Functional Linguistics
(SFL), a theory developed by Halliday that the meticulous examination of transitivity
patterns within textual or discursive contexts has yielded scholarly insights into the
intricate processes of meaning construction, elucidating the nuanced utilization of
language to articulate precise messages or convey distinct ideological tenets. However,
little focus was given to Priyantha Kumara's murder using Transitivity Analysis.
Therefore, this study investigates the transitivity patterns employed in Pakistani and Sri
Lankan English newspaper editorials to represent mob violence with reference to
lynching of Priyantha Kumara (A Sri Lankan citizen). Eight newspapers were selected;
among them, four were the newspapers of Pakistan titled The DAWN, International the
News, Daily Times and The Dayspring, and the rest of the four were Sri-Lankan
newspapers with the title: Colombo Telegraph, Daily Newspaper, Daily Mirror Online
and The Island Online. Drawing on Halliday's model of transitivity patterns, the study
employs mixed method approach to identify similarities and differences in the editorials
and explore how these patterns construct underlying realities regarding mob violence
with reference to lynching of Priyantha Kumara. A total of ninety-six (96) clauses were
analyzed, forty-eight (48) from each country's newspaper, with mental and relational
processes emerging as the most prominent. These patterns conveyed condemnation,
disgust, and the demand for justice while highlighting themes of religious extremism,
false allegations of blasphemy, crimes against humanity, discrimination, and
misunderstandings while demanding justice for the extra-judicial killing of Kumara. The
research contributes to understanding the linguistic strategies used in constructing public
narratives and provides valuable insights into the representation of significant events in
newspaper editorials.
Narrative Identity and the Rhetoric of Self Change: A comparative Analysis of Selected Memories
Title: Narrative Identity and the Rhetoric of Self-Change: A Comparative Analysis of
Selected Memoirs
This research study seeks to investigate two selected memoirs, i.e., Becoming (2018) and
My Feudal Lord (1995), by Michelle Obama and Tehmina Durrani, respectively. The theoretical
underpinnings of narrative identity, through the qualitative mode of inquiry, are applied
speculative lenses to unmask the problems faced by women while constructing their self-identity
under the patriarchal constraints of conservative as well as black American societies. Moreover,
the study focuses on cultural and social norms, patriarchy, religion, class, feudalism, and racism.
These established standards are the root cause of women’s oppression, stereotypical
discrimination, sociopolitical and economic exploitation, and intersectional subjugation across the
globe. Consequently, building an identity in a patriarchal environment is seen as an uphill task for
women. In this regard, the personality psychologists illustrate that the self-narrative helps to
reconstruct one’s own identity as the narrators (autobiographers) derive redemptive meanings out
of adversity, affliction, and calamities in their lives. They, consequently, tend to exhibit a higher
level of psychological maturity, generativity, and well-being. Substantially, in the 1980s this idea
of narrative identity was coined by Paul Ricoeur, a French philosopher. It is generally an
integrative psychological concept that bridges cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology,
and the humanities in the form of literary narrative. Narrative identity, however, has been further
modified by Dan P. McAdams and Kat C. McLean, in 2013. They have modified the critique under
seven coding constructs, i.e., agency, communication, redemption, contamination, meaning
making, ENP (Exploratory Narrative Processing), and CPR (Coherent Positive Resolution). The
study foregrounds the redemptive nature of the selected autobiographers and their contaminations
through the politics of memory in the selected memoirs under the lenses of these seven codes of
identity construction, Furthermore, the feminist theoretical analysis of the study is based on
Intersectionality, a concept introduced in 1989 by Kimberley Crenshaw.
An Investigation of Metadiscourse Markers in Medical research Articles on Covid-19: A corpus-Based Study
Title: An Exploration of Metadiscourse Markers in Medical Research Articles on
Covid-19: A Corpus-Based Study
The term "metadiscourse" describes the language strategies and components used in a
text that direct the reader's comprehension of the subject content besides demonstrating
the author's attitude, engagement and organization. This dissertation focuses on the
Metadiscourse Markers used by the authors in hundred Covid-19 articles published in
the well-known medical research journals. It is a Corpus-based study and uses Antconc
Software to analyze the frequencies of metadiscourse markers and the concordance
feature is being used in order to highlight the intended meanings. This research is based
on Hyland Model of Metadiscourse Markers (2005) which is used to explore the two
broad categories of Metadiscourse Markers i.e., Interactive and Interactional Markers
and their sub-categories. This is an attempt to comprehend the language and discourse
of the Covid articles, with roots in Hyland's Metadiscourse model. The research reveals
that authors of the medical research journals prefer interactive markers in their writings.
Within the subcategories, transitions (frequency; 18,483) are the most preferred and
engagement markers (frequency; 26) are the least preferred metadiscourse markers.
This research reveals how the language used by the authors in medical research journals
conveys their intentions and how language is a bridge between the reader and the
author. In order to effectively transmit meaning and engage readers, medical research
journal authors focus more on creating logical links within the text. Additionally, these
markers aid authors in appropriately conveying their viewpoints, beliefs, and ideas. The
analysis of the concordance lines reveal that authors use metadiscourse markers to
structure and organize the text, simplify the content, highlight essential points, link
ideas, interact with readers and express the degree of certainty and ambiguity in the
medical research journals.
Orienting Green Discourse: A Corpus-Based Ecolinguistic Study of Economic Discourse on the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
Orienting Green Discourse: A Corpus-based Ecolinguistic Study of Economic Discourse on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
This research explores the economic discourse produced around China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) by analyzing a corpus of 1.2 million words to find cognitive structures and linguistic patterns representing socioeconomic and ecological/environmental areas in the discourse of CPEC. In addition, this research also determines how identified linguistic patterns and cognitive structures develop six stories by following Stibbe’s (2015) story framework of eco-critical discourse perspective and Sen’s (1999) sustainable development approach. The data for this research is taken from the official website of CPEC, and the unofficial data comprising Pakistani and Chinese English newspapers (2016-2020) from online e-paper websites. The theoretical framework of this research includes theories from cognitive linguistics and discourse analysis. The corpus analysis provided frequencies and statistical significance scores to find frames, metaphors, salience, appraisal, and facticity patterns that helped discover the type of discourse/ideologies. Seventeen Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) provided a word list for corpus analysis.
The findings indicate that the representation of socioeconomic areas (5719 hits) and (CPEC-socioeconomic collocation =7.59442 MI score) in CPEC discourse is found to be more frequent as compared to the eco-environmental (1807) hits and (CPEC-ecoenvironmental collocation= 2.64534 MI score) representation in the CPEC discourse. The story of frames is developed through 55 socioeconomic frames (22 problem or extrinsic frames, 34 predicament or intrinsic frames) and 66 eco-environmental frames (40 problem or extrinsic frames, 26 predicament or intrinsic frames). The story of conceptual metaphors is developed through 12 metaphors for CPEC, 11 for socioeconomic, and 4 for ecoenvironmental areas of Pakistan. Some examples include: Nature is a resource, CPEC is a human being, poverty is a war, and Pakistan’s environment is a patient. The story of salience is employed in CPEC discourse with the help of verbs of focus, vitality, and
vi
significance such as explore, implement, accelerate, and promote. The most salient verb is ‘promote’, with salience stats 7.36823. Similarly, CPEC has been appraised well for bringing socioeconomic uplift to Pakistan using 51 positive appraisal items, primarily adjectives. In comparison, it has been appraised as bad for the environmental health of Pakistan by using 18 negative appraisal items. Facticity or conviction patterns have been employed using expert authorities’ opinions, such as environmentalists, economists, ministers, and field experts. Moreover, modal verbs such as: will are used most frequently with eight areas, and hedging words like believe/s and think/s, are also used in the collocation ‘environmentalists-believe’ (11.23230) and policy makers -- think (7.49041) to validate descriptions of socioeconomic and eco-environmental areas of CPEC discourse. The CPEC discourse is ambivalent due to the combination of 5 areas with anthropocentric ideologies and four areas with ecocentric ideologies. The Ecosophy of the CPEC discourse starts with anthropocentric ideologies and ends with ecocentric ones.
The Portability of Memory: A Psycho-spatial Analysis of Selected South Asian Dystopian Fiction
Title: The portability of memory: A Psycho-Spatial analysis of selected South Asian
Dystopian fiction
In this study, I attempt to look into the psycho-spatial orientation of the bystanders theorized as the
implicated subject, as a site for the embodiment of their secondary experiences in the form of memory. The
memory of the implicated subjects in the selected texts is analyzed in conjunction with prosthetic memory to
investigate their role in enabling the oppressive structures that they inhabit in speculative settings. The thesis
employs the psycho-spatial lens as a theoretical-methodological tool to reveal the socio-political
ramifications of the memories carried into the future by the implicated subjects. The research attempts to
contribute to the theoretical debates pertaining to the socio-political strategizing of memory, implicated
subject and the spatialization of technological and cultural conundrums in the regions of India and Pakistan.
The aim of the research is to examine the role of memory in constructing individual and collective identities
within speculative settings, as portrayed in the novels "Midnight Doorways" by Usman T Malik, "Chosen
Spirits" by Samit Basu, and "Leila" by Prayag Akbar. The study delves into the ramifications of socio-
political conflict and technological evolution in these speculative settings, focusing on the interplay of
psycho-spatiality. It investigates how the psycho-spatial orientation of characters and their memories in the
selected novels offer a profound commentary on socio-political conundrums. It also explores the indirect
responsibility of the protagonists in transmitting socio-political oppressive structures through the framework
of the implicated subject. The findings of the textual analysis of the given texts shed light on the
transformative impact of individuals in the construction and reimagining of the dystopian societies.
Linguistic Postioning of the Kashmir Issue in pakistani, Idian, and American Media Discourse: A corpus assisted Critical Discourse Analysis
Title: Linguistic Positioning of the Kashmir Issue in Pakistani, Indian, and
American Media Discourse: A Corpus-Assisted Critical Discourse Analysis
Since both India and Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the Kashmir issue has been at
the centre of a territorial dispute between the two nations. This study intends to investigate
how the print media has projected the Kashmir issue as it has been portrayed in editorials
and articles. For this purpose, the corpus-based approach is used to analyse editorials and
articles from Pakistani, Indian, and American newspapers from August 5, 2019, to
December 31, 2021. The research compares how the Kashmir issue is presented in the three
nations' newspapers by closely examining lexical items. Thus, three corpora totaling
169,680 words are created based on newspaper editorials and articles in three countries.
The newspaper editorials and articles are from renowned Pakistani, Indian and American
press outlets. The Baker (2008) model of concordance analysis of lexical items and the
Critical Discourse Analysis methodology proposed by van Dijk (2004) serve as the
theoretical framework for the study. A software tool like Antconc is used to analyse the
data. According to the results, Pakistani data was more frequent than the American and
Indian data. The findings reveal that three countries' publications presented Kashmir as
their property and used various lexical items depending on national interests. The three
principles of Van Dijk (2004) are described by the three corpora in different perspectives,
i.e., social power abuse, domination and inequality. Pakistani media blame India for social
power abuse, domination and unequal treatment of Kashmiris, while Indian media blame
Pakistan for all these. America, the neutral, somehow balances the situation but fails to
solve the issue according to UN security resolutions. Additionally, the results demonstrated
that the keyword 'Kashmir' has the highest frequency in all corpora. In order to obtain a
more thorough outcome, articles 370 and 35A should be quantitatively investigated in the
valley of Kashmir to get a more accurate perception of the Kashmiris.
The Body and the Witnessing: A Corporeal reading of the selected Covid-19 Pandemic literature
Title: The Body and the Witnessing: A Corporeal Reading of Female Precarity
in the Selected COVID-19 Pandemic Literature
This research examines female precarity during the COVID-19 pandemic in Sarah
Moss's The Fell (2021) and Sarah Hall's Burntcoat (2021). The study goes beyond the
physiological implications of the COVID-19 pandemic to include a capitalistic and
psychological analysis of The Fell and Burntcoat respectively. Judith Butler's concept
of precarity, along with Jose Medina and Tempest Henning's concept of bodily
testimony is employed to explore different forms of precarity faced by women during
the pandemic. More than its economic inferences, the focus is specifically on the
sociological aspect of capitalistic and psychological implications of COVID-19 on
women. By focusing on the body as the main point of study and studying its role in
tandem with the pandemic, the study investigates various forms of female precarity in
the selected texts and the role of the body as a witness to the COVID-19 crisis.
Furthermore, the study delves into how the protagonists' individual bodily testimonies
in the novels contribute to formulating a broader understanding of the collective
bodily testimony related to the COVID-19 crisis. This research is an important
addition to the scholarship related to the COVID-19 pandemic and the burgeoning
field of medical humanities. It also gives a new dimension to the concept of precarity,
previously limited to neoliberalism, by studying it in relation to a medical
phenomenon. This research may help in understanding the pandemic beyond its
physiology and prepare people to combat such crises in the future
Emplotment in Covid-19 News Reports of print media: A Narratological Study
This research aimed to investigate the narrativity feature in print media news
reports by analyzing their emplotment structure. Although newspapers have received
considerable attention in research, there has been a lack of detailed study on the
narratological analysis of news reports using the approach employed in this study.
Conducting such research is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of the structure of
news reports. To achieve this objective, the researchers selected widely circulated
Pakistani newspapers, namely DAWN, THE NEWS, and THE NATION, as the primary
source of textual data.The analysis focused on identifying emplotment by examining the
textual constructions of temporal markers and tense in media narratives. Through
qualitative textual analysis, the researchers identified patterns of emplotment based on the
event structures found in these reports. The theoretical foundation of the analysis drew
from the work of linguists William F. Brewer, Edward H. Lichtenstein, and Genette.
Following the proposed model, the analysis constructed an event structure that revealed
the emplotment structure and the presence of narrativity features in the news reports. The
findings highlighted the contribution of discourse patterns, particularly tense and
temporal markers, to the emplotment of the news reports. These structural arrangements,
expressed through temporal markers and tense, played a significant role in ensuring
continuity and coherence in the text. Based on these findings, several recommendations
are proposed. First, there is a need to enhance awareness among journalists and news
organizations about the narrativity feature in news reports. This awareness will help them
understand the importance of the emplotment structure and its impact on the overall
narrative quality of news articles. Second, organizing training programs and workshops
for journalists to develop their narrative construction skills and effectively utilize
temporal markers can improve the coherence and flow of news reports, thereby
enhancing their readability and impact.
Third, it is crucial to encourage further research in the field of narratology and
news reporting, specifically focusing on exploring different aspects of narrativity and
emplotment. This additional research will contribute to a deeper understanding of the
vi
narrative structures in news reports and their influence on readers. Lastly, developing
editorial guidelines that emphasize the significance of temporal markers and tense in
constructing news narratives is recommended. These guidelines should highlight the
necessity of maintaining consistency and clarity in temporal references throughout news
articles. By implementing these recommendations, news organizations can enhance the
narrative quality of their reports and improve reader engagement and understanding
Tweet on Racal and Religious Anti-Discrimination: A Discursive analysis of Social Media Hashtags
Title: Tweets on Racial and Religious Anti-Discrimination: A Discursive Analysis of
Social Media Hashtags
This qualitative study employs Van Dijk's framework of discourse analysis to examine
the nuances of online anti-discriminatory discourse within the context of religious and
racial anti-discrimination. Focusing on the dynamic and powerful platform of Twitter, the
study investigates the discursive strategies and linguistic patterns employed in 24
carefully selected tweets. Specifically, the research delves into the discourse generated
under two prominent hashtags: #BlackLivesMatter and #MuslimLivesMatter. The study
is grounded in the understanding that online platforms serve as arenas where individuals
and groups engage in discursive practices that reflect, shape, and contest prevailing
ideologies, power dynamics, and socio-political contexts. Van Dijk's framework provides
a systematic and multidisciplinary lens to analyze how language is harnessed to construct
meaning, reinforce social hierarchies, and challenge discriminatory narratives. Through a
meticulous selection process, 12 tweets from each of the hashtags are chosen, allowing
for an in-depth analysis of discourse variation across these distinct anti-discriminatory
movements. By focusing on these hashtags, the research highlights the experiences of
marginalized communities within the broader narrative of anti-discrimination activism.
Findings from the study reveal how discursive strategies are strategically employed to
counter dominant narratives and create counter-narratives that challenge established
power structures. Additionally, the research uncovers linguistic cues that convey
solidarity, empathy, and alliance building among online communities engaging with the
hashtags. The implications of this study extend to both theoretical and practical domains.
The application of Van Dijk's framework enriches our understanding of how language
contributes to shaping social change, as well as the interconnectedness between online
and offline discursive practices. Moreover, insights drawn from the analysis offer avenues
for developing effective communication strategies to counter discrimination and promote
inclusivity within digital spaces.
The Postmodern Museum and the Interdependence of Memory and Representation in Orhan Pamuk’s The Museum of Innocence and Selected Photographs of Ara Guler
Title: The Postmodern Museum and the Interdependence of Memory and
Representation in Orhan Pamuk’s The Museum of Innocence and Selected
Photographs of Ara Güler
This thesis analyzes both literary and visual narratives including Pamuk’s novel The
Museum of Innocence (2008), his physical museum, The Museum of Innocence, and
selected photographs of Ara Güler in order to identify the interdependence of memory
and representation. This study examines how the selected objects of study portray the
fragmented nature of memories. It also analyzes how both the artists i.e. Güler and Pamuk
have preserved the memories of Istanbul in their works. Apart from memory and its
representation this thesis also examines the shift in the role of museums in the
postmodern world by taking the example of Pamuk’s museum, The Museum of
Innocence. This study is grounded in the theoretical concepts of two literary and cultural
theorists namely Andreas Huyssen and Meike Bal. The method used for the analysis of
the novel is textual analysis whereas, for the interpretation of the visual narratives i.e.
photographs and the museum, this thesis has made a methodological intervention by
triangulating Lacan’s notion of the Gaze with Huyssen, Bal, and Pamuk’s theorization of
museums. This research concludes that both the novel and the photos as a medium of
re-presentation reconceptualize memory through the artists’ subjective intervention
which leads to the fragmented portrayal of the memory. It also identifies that this
reconceptualization ultimately preserves memory. Furthermore, it also reveals that in the
postmodern age museums, on the one hand, have become sites of cultural authority and
on the other hand, play a pivotal role in enhancing consumerism through the
commodification of art.