Representation of Violence Against Women in Pakistani Print Media Discourse: A Corpus-based Feminist Stylistic Analysis
This research study has attempted to analyse the representation issues of violence against women in Pakistani print media discourse. The researcher has applied a feminist stylistic approach given by Mills (2005) as a lens to analyse it. To benefit from the strengths of both quantitative and qualitative analysis, a mixed method approach was adopted. Corpus-based method was adopted for quantitative analysis and the in depth analysis was carried out using feminist stylistic model. The corpus was created by taking 110 articles from the four major English newspapers in Pakistan. A purposive sampling technique was adopted based on the online availability of these articles and their relevance to the study. The articles covering the issues of domestic violence and sexual abuse were selected. The corpus was analysed on three levels; lexical choices (word level), syntactic choices (phrase level), words in context and correlations (discourse level). Use of adjectives and adverbs was analysed in binary opposition i.e. for man/woman, victim/perpetrator, frequency of the words victim/ survivor and rapist/perpetrator was also analysed to investigate media’s preference of use of specific terms. Key words were analysed in context and collocations of certain words were also explored. In addition, the use of active and passive constructions was also analysed. The results of the study show that the media’s use of language for the representation of violence against women issues is biased and guided by the ideological conventions of society. Some of these features of language like the use of passive constructions and silencing of women’s voices through omission as well as over-lexicalisation of certain ideas reinforce the stereotypes that already exist in society rather than discouraging them. The research concludes that media’s representation of violence against women issues needs to be more conscientious and astute.
Morphing Subjectivities, Shifting Agencies: A Metamodern Perspective on American Science Fiction
ABSTRACT
Morphing Subjectivities, Shifting Agencies: A Metamodern Perspective on American Science Fiction
This study investigates human subjectivity and its manifestation from a metamodern perspective in the American science fiction digital series Orphan Black and its graphic novel adaptation. Keeping in line with the metamodern view, this thesis conceptualizes the said human subjectivity as an oscillation between two extremes inherent in the spectrum of self. This constant alternation results in an entity that is an amalgam of both positions. It yet does not have the characteristics of either of them, occupying a place that is not a place in the physical and spatial sense of the word. The continuous sway gives the subject the freedom to transcend the boundaries otherwise inherent in the two polarities, resulting in a multi-dimensional manifestation of self that can morph as and when required. The study also makes use of transmedia storytelling as an additional prong in the theoretical framework to comment on the form and medium of the selected texts and discusses how these play a key role in allowing the subjectivity to manifest multiply. To achieve its goal, the study employs textual analysis under the qualitative paradigm to analyze the selected works. The notion of multiple subjectivity is projected as human cloning in Orphan Black and, in doing so, the works reflect the multi-faceted nature of an individual in the contemporary digital age. The study explores how this multiplicity, and its consequences manifest and aims to develop an understanding of this natural order in the metamodernist world.
Re-Orientalizing the Orient: A Self-Orientalist Perspective on Afghan Anglophone Fiction
ABSTRACT
Title: Re-Orientalizing the Orient: A Self-Orientalist Perspective on Afghan Anglophone Fiction
This dissertation is a postcolonial study of Afghan Anglophone fiction. It is delimited to Khalid Hosseini’s The Kite Runner and And the Mountains Echoed and Atiq Rahimi’s The Patience Stone. Located on a larger scale in Afghan Anglophone literary tradition and focused on narratives written by diasporic writers, this investigation is in the area of Orientalists discourses, contributed by Afghan Anglophone writers. The main argument of this study is that, through their construction of relational, hybrid, multiple, and shifting subjectivities/identities in their narratives, diasporic writers have appropriated the Western cannon. In this context Afghan Anglophone writers; Khalid Hosseini and Atiq Rahimi endorse Orientalists discourses and coin the self-othering concept of the Orient. The concept is called Self-Orientalism while the process is called Re-Orientalism. The main argument of the research is the Re-Orientalization the Orient from self-Orientalist perspective. Afghanistan has always been an arena for international conflicts and has served as a buffer zone for the world powers wherein to settle their disputes. The decades long wars and turbulences have left the country devastated and its people vulnerable. And as such it has not yet passed that phase of being a lucrative part of the orient, worthy of the representation and stereotyping of the west, as well as its own people. The present study tries to examine what such self-representations might entail. For this purpose, Hosseini’ s The Kite Runner, And The Mountains Echoed and Rahimi’s The Patience Stone have been selected which are the stories of men and women’s tormented inner self in search of voice and many other stereotypes labeled on Afghans. Orientalism theory by Edward Said, Re- orientalization theory by Lisa Lau, Dirlik’s theory of Self-Orientalism have been used as theoretical framework. Said’s Orientalism has been consulted as a background theory. The findings of the study underline that the culturally indiscrete portrayal of Afghani identity is actually a colonial portrayal, by the author in a postcolonial era. Moreover, the claim for authentic representation ends up in self-stereotyping and misrepresentation of the
v
diverse ethnic groups within the country because the strategies of representation used by the authors are not devoid of their inherent politics and are, thus, ethical and political in nature. Furthermore, the sense of self in a postcolonial era and the hegemony of “us” and “them” within the self in the context of Afghanistan have also been highlighted in this analysis.
"Remaking of the Self: A Study of Generational Trauma and Collective Memory in Post-Colonial Caribbean Fiction "
The research study explores the depiction of generational trauma and collective memory in the novels An
Untamed State by Roxane Gay and Breath, Eyes, Memory by Edwidge Danticat. The focus of the study is
delimited to Haitian fiction that commonly portrays issues of gender abuse and violence. The study
investigates how the traumatic events of kidnappings, and rape, in post-colonial Haitian setting, impact
female characters over generations. The study utilizes Victoria Aarons and Alan L. Berger’s “Generational
Trauma”, Maurice Halbwachs’ “Collective Memory”, and Susan J. Brison’s “Remaking of a Self” as a
conceptual framework. This research study shows how these female characters, subjected to violence,
experience the trauma of sexual and physical abuse and engage with it during different generations of a
family. First-generation females experience traumatic events; second-generation (children of trauma
survivors) experience trauma either directly or indirectly, but they work to discover who they are while
shielding the third generation from the effects of trauma. Brison’s concept has been utilized to see how
female characters demonstrate incredible courage and perseverance in the face of traumatic events and
attain female agency. Mireille, and Sophie as mothers are pivotal in the novels because they hold the family
together and fight for the third generation. The second generation shows resistance through the collective
memory of a family to stop the transference of generational trauma to the next generation and transform
their “Self” to claim their place in society. These female trauma survivors attain agency by redefining who
they are as women. The collective memory of the past traumatic events, experienced by the female
characters in a family, also provides this fortitude and preparedness for the second generations. Trauma and
the collective memory of the family passed down through generations work together to restore the victim’s
“Self”. This newfound agency and sense of self assist women in normalizing their family after generational
trauma.
REPRESENTATION OF CPEC IN PAKISTANI ENGLISH NEWSPAPERS: A READER RESPONSE PERSPECTIVE
Title: Representation Of CPEC In Pakistani English Newspapers: A Reader Response
Perspective
This work explores the representation of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor
(CPEC) in Pakistani English newspapers from a reader response perspective. The
study aims to understand the evolution of CPEC's depiction over time and the factors
influencing these changes. The work employs a qualitative analysis methods to
evaluate the perception of readers for CPEC coverage. The key concepts discussed in
this thesis include the geopolitical significance of CPEC, the media's role in shaping
public opinion, and the influence of political dynamics on media narratives. Through
qualitative analysis of interview data from various respondents, the research identifies
themes such as initial optimism, emerging environmental and economic concerns, and
the impact of political shifts on media coverage. The findings reveal a transition from
a predominantly positive portrayal to a more refined and critical perspective,
reflecting broader geopolitical tensions and domestic political changes. While readers
express general satisfaction with timeliness and accuracy, the study identifies a need
for subtle reporting that addresses concerns about comprehensiveness and fairness.
The conclusion underscores the complex interaction between media, politics, and
public perception in shaping the narrative around CPEC. The study highlights the
need for responsible journalism that balances national interests with objective
reporting, especially on projects with significant economic and political implications.
This research enhances the understanding of media's role in international relations
and offers valuable insights for policymakers, media professionals, and scholars in
communication and international studies.
SPATIAL LEGIBILITY: A STUDY OF THE INTERACTION BETWEEN THE SELECTED CHARACTERS AND KARACHI IN THE WORKS OF OMAR SHAHID HAMID AND SAMIRA SHACKLE
Title: Spatial Legibility: A Study of the Interaction between the Selected Characters and
Karachi in the Works of Omar Shahid Hamid and Samira Shackle.
This study delves into the intricate relationship between imageability and legibility in
urban environments, with a particular focus on hyper-mediated cities. It critically
examines the concept of phantasmagoria within urban literature, analyzing two significant
novels: The Party Worker by Omar Shahid Hamid and Karachi Vice: Life and Death in a
Contested City by Samira Shackle. The primary objective of this research is to
comprehend how phantasmagoria affects the legibility of Karachi as an urban space.
Through a detailed textual analysis, this study explores the mental representations and
perceptions of Karachi's inhabitants as depicted in these fictional narratives, placing
emphasis on the city's strategies to desensitize and manipulate the human sensorium. By
employing the theoretical perspectives of urban scholars such as Kevin Lynch, Libero
Andreotti, and Nadir Lahiji, this research offers a critical analysis of the selected texts,
drawing out key insights into the construction of spatio-temporal images of Karachi. The
findings of this study contribute to the broader academic discourse on urban legibility,
highlighting the significant role of phantasmagoria in shaping and influencing perceptions
of urban spaces. Ultimately, this study enhances our understanding of how sensory
manipulation and mediated imagery in literature reflect and impact the legibility of urban
environments, particularly within the context of Karachi.
Graphic Narratives and Sociopolitical Discourse: A Critical Study of the Selected Graphic Novels of Joe Sacco and Malik Sajad
This research deals with graphic narratives whose multimodality characterizes their genre,
meaning that graphic narratives have a unique form of storytelling that combines both
visual and textual elements to convey meaningful narratives. The current research, keeping
in view this unique aspect of graphic narratives, analyzes two graphic texts Paying the Land
(2020) by Joe Sacco and Munnu: A Boy from Kashmir (2015) by Malik Sajad. These are
analyzed in the light of the theoretical framework developed from the works of comic and
political theorists to address socio-political issues in two different geospatial contexts. The
analysis follows two trajectories. Firstly, it focuses on their medium-specific combination
of verbal-visual features such as frames, panels, graphic style, and page layout, to name a
few, and secondly, how these graphic novels frame the socio-political stance on the
documented crisis. Paying the Land is particularly analyzed for its subversion of dominant
political discourse regarding Dene in Canada, and Munnu for problematizing the
sociopolitical violence in Kashmir via the medium of comics. The findings suggest that
Paying the Land brings to fore an alternate discourse regarding the Dene crisis in Canada
foregrounding the importance of indigenous perspectives, agency, and cultural resilience.
Through its multimodal aesthetics, it not only acts as a vehicle for truth-telling but also
advocates indigenous rights and self-determination. Findings also suggest that Munnu
serves as a powerful critique of sociopolitical violence in Kashmir owing to its graphic
novel format. The discussion is expanded beyond this to account for how the documented
crises are framed to influence readers to form a certain perspective of reality and to
encourage their active engagement for the cause that graphic narratives represent. The
visual culture of graphic novels is thus addressed establishing that it plays a significant role
in highlighting and disseminating global issues. Through their unique combination of
visual-verbal aesthetics, and storytelling techniques, graphic narratives engage, raise
awareness, inspire action, and create solidarities of marginalized voices at a transnational
level.
"Cultural Trauma and Re-construction of Identity: A Study of Selected Palestinian War Narratives"
This study investigates the concept of cultural trauma in the selected Palestinian short
fiction. It examines ten short stories by different Palestinian writers, including Hanan
Habashi’s “L for Life,” Rawan Yaghi’s “Spared,” Sarah Ali’s “The Story of the Land,”
Nour Al-Sousi’s “Will I Ever Get Out?” Jehan Alfarra’s “Please Shoot to Kill,” Yousef
Aljamal’s “Omar X,” Randa Jarrar’s “Barefoot Bridge,” and Mohammed Suliman’s
“We Shall Return,” “One War Day,” and “Bundles.” The analysis of the traumatic
experiences of the characters is framed through the theoretical lens of Kai T. Erikson’s
concept of collective trauma and Jeffrey C. Alexander’s conceptualization of cultural
trauma. In this study, Erikson’s collective trauma works to highlight the trauma of a
community. The study analyzes horrendous events of war and examines damaged social
bonds that leave a traumatic impact on the consciousness of the community. The
analysis of collective trauma in the short stories underscores a rupture of social bonds
within the social setting and highlights an erosion of communal ties that the characters
experience. This representation of collective trauma, through the suffering of different
characters, marks the relation of trauma victim to the wider audience. Building on this
foundation, the study further examines how these short stories construct claims of
trauma that are mediated through aesthetic realm of cultural trauma. The study argues
that the writers of the short stories act as carrier groups who represent the pain of their
community. This representation transforms individual and collective suffering into a
cultural trauma that resonates beyond the immediate context of the suffering
community. The study highlights trauma claims through these narratives, which not
only work to identify the sources of suffering of a collectivity but also implore moral
responsibility within and beyond the suffering community. This research further
underscores that by operating within the aesthetic realm of cultural trauma, these texts
contribute to the reconstruction of Palestinian identity.
PERCEPTIONS OF PAKISTANI PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS ABOUT THE INFLUENCE OF POPULAR SOCIAL MEDIA: A SOCIOLINGUISTICS EXPLORATORY STUDY
Title: Perceptions of Pakistani Primary School Teachers about the Influence of
Popular Social Media: A Sociolinguistic Exploratory Study
The present study was aimed at investigating the perception of Pakistani primary school
teachers regarding the impact of using popular social media platforms on their English
spoken skills. Social media platforms are major sources of social interaction now days.
Social media has significantly impacted language use in various ways such as speaking
and writing. The advent of the internet and the significant collection of social media
networks have led to a massive upsurge in new types of written language: blogs, tweets,
Face book posts, Instagram status etc. Social media platforms are used globally for
interactive communication. The present work is an exploratory research which used
qualitative method to collect data in the form of interviews and classroom observations.
The study explored the perceptions of Pakistani primary school teachers about the
influence of popular social media on spoken English. It investigated the specific
changes or trends primary school teachers perceive in their spoken English language
that can be attributed to the influence of popular social media. Interviews and
observations were used to collect data from primary school teachers. The data analysis
revealed that social media has impacted the ways teachers communicate in English
language in many aspects. Closeness with social media resulted in increase of
vocabulary related to diverse fields of human life, use of contractions, code-mixing,
code-switching, and use of informal language in teachers’ communication. The findings
of this study have contributed in understanding of a new dimension in teaching learning
environment with social media platforms which will benefit both learners and
facilitators in spoken English language.
“SUSTAINING CULTURE OF VIOLENCE”: A STUDY OF SELECTED CONTEMPORARY SOUTH ASIAN FICTION IN ENGLISH
ABSTRACT
Title: “Sustaining Culture of Violence”: A Study of Selected Contemporary South
Asian Fiction in English
South Asian communities have witnessed a meteoric rise in the events of violence and
terrorism in the wake of 9/11. Shamise’s Burnt Shadows, Hosseini’s A Thousand
Splendid Suns and Tanweer’s The Scatter Here is Too Great are examples of literary
works that represent this surge in violence and terrorism; representing the nexus between
violence and culture in South Asian communities. This study highlights why high levels
of violence in the community, such as bomb blasts, killings, political and social
upheavals often persist in what Steenkamp has termed as “post-accord societies”.
Furthermore, this study discusses that the period of extended violent conflicts has given a
drastic expansion to a “Culture of Violence”, which goes on an extra mile and creates a
socially permissive environment within which violence can be continued even after peace
accords have been signed. This thesis utilizes the conceptual framework of violence and
types of violence theorized by Slavoj Žižek and the conceptualization of the culture of
violence which is mapping the dynamics of violent intra-state conflict as presented by
Christina Steenkamp. The study investigates the factors that create and sustain culture of
violence at the international, state, collective and individual levels in post-accord
societies and communities. The study also analyzes the consequences and impacts of
culture of violence on the lives of communities by non-state actors, groups and
institutions through the analysis of the lives of the main characters and their interpersonal
relations.
PHONOLOGICAL VARIATIONS AT SEGMENTAL AND SUPRA-SEGMENTAL LEVEL IN NON-NATIVE ENGLISH SPEECH: A CASE STUDY OF DISTRICT MIANWALI
ABSTRACT
Title: Phonological Variations at Segmental and Supra-Segmental Level in Non-
Native English Speech
5
The present study is conducted to explore the variations in the English speech of its
non-native learners. The study aims to examine the segmental and supra segmental
features in the English speech of students with a Saraiki background in the northern
region of Punjab. The current study specifically explores the variations present in
English speakers with Saraiki as their mother tongue in the district, Mianwali. Many
remarkable works have been carried out in the central variety of Saraiki language, but
linguistically, the present work is the first study of the phonological and phonetic
aspects of variations in the English speech of students in the public sector colleges in
the city. The primary objective of the current research is to identify different linguistic
variations produced by Saraiki speaking students in their English pronunciation;
moreover, the study is designed to evaluate the impacts of gender has on the
variations. The secondary objective of the study is to introduce the northern variety of
Saraiki to the linguistic world for further study. All the data were collected in a formal
setting. For phonological level evaluation, the data was transcribed, and all the
deviations were carefully marked by the researcher in the pronunciation. For
analyzing the phonetic features, the PRAAT software version 6.2.1 is used. The
variations were evaluated by comparing the collected data with Standard British
English (RP) through the application of Contrastive Analysis (CA). The only two
consonant sounds analyzed in the study were /t/ and /r/. The findings, after data
analysis, showed a mostly strong and occasionally medium relationship between
variations in the RP. As far as the factor of gender was concerned, the results show a
weak relationship. The researcher tried to counter all possible reasons behind the
variations found in the speech of Saraiki speaking students of English. Eventually,
possible ideas to counter these variations and areas of possible future research were
also discussed.
PHONOLOGICAL VARIATIONS AT SEGMENTAL AND SUPRA-SEGMENTAL LEVEL IN NON-NATIVE ENGLISH SPEECH: A CASE STUDY OF DISTRICT MIANWALI
ABSTRACT
Title: Phonological Variations at Segmental and Supra-Segmental Level in Non-
Native English Speech
5
The present study is conducted to explore the variations in the English speech of its
non-native learners. The study aims to examine the segmental and supra segmental
features in the English speech of students with a Saraiki background in the northern
region of Punjab. The current study specifically explores the variations present in
English speakers with Saraiki as their mother tongue in the district, Mianwali. Many
remarkable works have been carried out in the central variety of Saraiki language, but
linguistically, the present work is the first study of the phonological and phonetic
aspects of variations in the English speech of students in the public sector colleges in
the city. The primary objective of the current research is to identify different linguistic
variations produced by Saraiki speaking students in their English pronunciation;
moreover, the study is designed to evaluate the impacts of gender has on the
variations. The secondary objective of the study is to introduce the northern variety of
Saraiki to the linguistic world for further study. All the data were collected in a formal
setting. For phonological level evaluation, the data was transcribed, and all the
deviations were carefully marked by the researcher in the pronunciation. For
analyzing the phonetic features, the PRAAT software version 6.2.1 is used. The
variations were evaluated by comparing the collected data with Standard British
English (RP) through the application of Contrastive Analysis (CA). The only two
consonant sounds analyzed in the study were /t/ and /r/. The findings, after data
analysis, showed a mostly strong and occasionally medium relationship between
variations in the RP. As far as the factor of gender was concerned, the results show a
weak relationship. The researcher tried to counter all possible reasons behind the
variations found in the speech of Saraiki speaking students of English. Eventually,
possible ideas to counter these variations and areas of possible future research were
also discussed.
PHONOLOGICAL VARIATIONS AT SEGMENTAL AND SUPRA-SEGMENTAL LEVEL IN NON-NATIVE ENGLISH SPEECH: A CASE STUDY OF DISTRICT MIANWALI
________________________
Date
v
ABSTRACT
Title: Phonological Variations at Segmental and Supra-Segmental Level in NonNative English Speech
The present study is conducted to explore the variations in the English speech of its
non-native learners. The study aims to examine the segmental and supra segmental
features in the English speech of students with a Saraiki background in the northern
region of Punjab. The current study specifically explores the variations present in
English speakers with Saraiki as their mother tongue in the district, Mianwali. Many
remarkable works have been carried out in the central variety of Saraiki language, but
linguistically, the present work is the first study of the phonological and phonetic
aspects of variations in the English speech of students in the public sector colleges in
the city. The primary objective of the current research is to identify different linguistic
variations produced by Saraiki speaking students in their English pronunciation;
moreover, the study is designed to evaluate the impacts of gender has on the
variations. The secondary objective of the study is to introduce the northern variety of
Saraiki to the linguistic world for further study. All the data were collected in a formal
setting. For phonological level evaluation, the data was transcribed, and all the
deviations were carefully marked by the researcher in the pronunciation. For
analyzing the phonetic features, the PRAAT software version 6.2.1 is used. The
variations were evaluated by comparing the collected data with Standard British
English (RP) through the application of Contrastive Analysis (CA). The only two
consonant sounds analyzed in the study were /t/ and /r/. The findings, after data
analysis, showed a mostly strong and occasionally medium relationship between
variations in the RP. As far as the factor of gender was concerned, the results show a
weak relationship. The researcher tried to counter all possible reasons behind the
variations found in the speech of Saraiki speaking students of English. Eventually,
possible ideas to counter these variations and areas of possible future research were
also discussed.
"The Human Condition and Repressive Regimes: A Reading of the Existentialist Values in the Selected Works of Kafka, Kobayashi and Gomikawa"
This study seeks to draw comparisons and simultaneously abridge the philosophical gap between the existentialist theories of Hannah Arendt and the Kyoto School, considerably those of Nishida Kitaro and Keiji Nishitani. Franz Kafka’s short story “The Penal Colony” is interpreted along with the first volume of Junpei Gomikawa and Masaki Kobayashi’s film, The Human Condition under the theorization of Hannah Arendt and the Kyoto School to address the existential problem of the human condition shaped by oppressive regimes. A mixed methodology of Qualitative Content Analysis and hermeneutics has been deployed for interpreting the selected works. The discussion and the analysis highlight the common understanding of how oppressive regimes normalize violent and abnormal acts, which is explained under concepts such as the Banality of Evil, the theory of political action, the logic of absolute nothingness, and the rise of fascism around the period of World War Two. The Hermeneutic Content Analysis revealed two different approaches to the problem of existentialism (the human condition) put forth by Hannah Arendt and the Kyoto School. While Arendt’s lens recognizes life’s inherent absurdity, the latter uses spiritual ideals such as those of Zen Buddhism to ascribe a meaning beyond nihilism, advocating for individual action deprived of ‘ego’, ‘self’, and ‘being’. This approach emphasizes mindfulness and the interconnectedness of all things, encouraging a compassionate and selfless way of living. By transcending personal desires and attachments, individuals can find a deeper sense of purpose and harmony within the universe, aligning their actions with a greater spiritual truth.